[Assam] [WaterWatch] Did Govt's flood forecasting & embankments help?

Mon Sep 3 10:15:50 CDT 2007

Fundamental Questions:

 Govt's flood forecasting: 

Under what authority does GOVT forecasts?
 Is GOVT bound to be correct,timely and help-relief-rendering-compensating?
Which GOVT--State/Central? As per "Our Sacred Constitution -framed by FF's"
What if they turn around and say "None of my jobs-Mate,I am busy GOVTing"
And National Embankment Policy: TO-:-(-60 years of Planned Disaster for FREE INDIA)

 deposit all of eroded Himalayas on the Bottom of Rivers
 not allow Alluvium to reach the farmlands on both banks
thereby fast depleting humus in its entire valley
thereby making it essential to use heavier and heavier doses of NPK+micronutrients
thereby enriching oil/gas cos supplying inputs to manufacture Ureabut having no source of P&K minerals in whole of India starving all agriculture of N,K,microelements
thereby making India depend  more and more on huge imports of Oil/Gas/fertilizers
AND as the riverbeds get more and more blocked-floods disaster increase year on year
and as the Nation raises the Embankments yet higher-the floods stay locked longer++
and people lose everything they saved-including health,cattle,lives-- every year more++ 
But Bharat Claims ALMOST-SUPER-POWER and MAHAAN status
LONG LIVE NATIONAL EMBANKMENTS !!!
mm

To: WaterWatch at yahoogroups.comFrom: pcsharma_bpl at bsnl.inDate: Thu, 30 Aug 2007 20:26:11 +0530Subject: Re: [WaterWatch] Did Govt's flood forecasting & embankments help?

It would be an interesting research project for the academia to study the impact of views expressed in various forum including this one, in changing the situation.So far what we have noticed is our ruling class does not care for public opinion and gets the media manipulated conveniently.King does no wrong.
Piyush C.Sharma

----- Original Message ----- 
From: Chan Mahanta 
To: WaterWatch at yahoogroups.com 
Cc: assam at assamnet.org 
Sent: Wednesday, August 29, 2007 7:31 PM
Subject: Re: [WaterWatch] Did Govt's flood forecasting & embankments help?

>We can only vent our feelings in forums like this but can not do anything to change the situation.

*** Absolutely NOT TRUE!

I know it is easy for me to say. But each one of us can and ought be doing something about it. Question is HOW?

Let us be analytical. Keep asking the questions until we can pin down WHY it happens. And once we get to the root cause/s, start doing something about it.

Mind you, it will need some commitment--on the part of the intelligentsia, which has been absent from its governance.

Elections are not the be-all and end-all of democratic governance.  It is merely a process for selecting a crew to run the ship of state. But if the electors do that on the basis of "Cast your vote--vote your caste", or mis-information, dis-information and no-information on ISSUES that so affect their lives, the chances of your getting a slate of representatives even barely competent to govern is about slim to none. Such a 'democratic' government is useful only to wave at the developed world who go ga-ga over the 'successes' of Indian democracy.  But we know a whole lot better, don't we?

Now then, can this democratically elected 'crew'  take the ship of state anywhere if the sails are torn, the mast is down, the hull is leaky and the sailors on duty drunk? That is the condition that defines Indian INSTITUTIONS of government--which have been existing ONLY on paper, dysfunctional to the core. Am I exaggerating? You tell us.

But WHO will change things?

A simple answer would be : An informed polity. Not the uninformed, not the disenfranchised, not those tottering at the brink of survival. Nor would the ESTABLISHMENT who profits handsomely for the dysfunctional state, and its  REVERSE ROBIN-HOODISM of stealing from the many to enrich a few, even if only by default.

So, I would submit, the only way to take government  BACK from the non-performers and scoundrels  and give it back to the people-- if it ever was theirs -- will be to begin at the beginning: Radical reforms with the system of elections, political parties and its formations, radically reforming the institutions of state, re-writing the Constitution with clear separation of powers between lawmaking, administration and the judiciary--- so on and so forth. I can go on and on. If you wish, I will be even be pleased to.

Question is whether Indian intelligentsia really cares, and if it does, whether it can muster the  courage and has the wherewithal to, at long last, begin to do its share for their collective well-being.

But having watched the scene in desperation for decades, I am NOT about to hold my breath!

cm

At 4:01 PM +0530 8/28/07, Piyush Sharma wrote:
I agree with the note in general. The last two paragraphs, i.e." General feeling is....have more than doubled" and  "Victims of flood.... are being built"are apt and factual statements. The pity is that our "ruling class" are immune to public opinion. They do not have time to ponder over public interest as they are too busy with self interest. Increasing GDP does not reflect the general well being of the '"ruled class ". 
My own house was flooded by 3 ft.deep water in the rooms due to the flooded Nala( Natural rain water drain) on August 14. 2006. We are still trying to recover from the physical and mental set back. Surely more funds will be allotted by the Government  to our Civic Bodies for urban Renewal out of which a trickle might be utilized for actual works that too substandard. We are always at the receiving end without proper "power connection".We can only vent our feelings in forums like this but can not do anything to change the situation.
Piyush C.Sharma

----- Original Message -----
From: mediavigil at yahoo.co.in
To: waterwatch at yahoogroups.com
Sent: Thursday, August 23, 2007 12:24 AM
Subject: [WaterWatch] Did Govt's flood forecasting & embankments help?

Did Govt's flood forecasting & embankments help?Flood forecasting has been recognized as one of the most important, reliable and cost-effective non-structural measures for flood management.Central Water Commission, Ministry of Water Resources has set up a network of forecasting stations covering all important flood prone interstate rivers.The forecasts issued by these stations are used to alert the Public and to enable the administrative and engineering agencies of the States/UT's to take appropriate measures.Central Water Commission started flood-forecasting services in 1958 with the setting up of its first forecasting station on Yamuna at Delhi Railway Bridge.The website of Ministry of Water Resources claims that it has at present a vast network of 945 hydrological observation stations and issues level forecast for 145 sites and inflow forecasts of 28 dam barrage sites located on main rivers.It also says that "The web site provides latest forecasts issued by the divisions of CWC." but if one visits it one only find one message: "The page cannot be found".Hundreds of people are reported to have lost their lives and many more lost everything they owned when the waters rose in North Bihar.For people across 300 villages in Koshi, flood and waterlogging is a yearlong problems because the very embankments that are meant to stop the flood have stopped it for good letting water stagnate.General feeling is that it is the contractors, politicians and bureaucrats who stand to gain from the projects set up to build and maintain these embankments. Over several decades thousands of kilometers of embankments have been built but flood prone areas in have more than doubled.Victims of flood do not have any voice in whose name newer and bigger embankments are being built.

__._,_.___ 
Messages in this topic (0) Reply (via web post) | Start a new topic 
Messages | Files | Photos | Links | Database | Polls | Calendar 

 Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required) Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch format to Traditional Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe 

Recent Activity

 4
New MembersVisit Your Group 

Yahoo! Finance
It's Now Personal
Guides, news,
advice & more.

Y! Messenger
Files to share?
Send up to 1GB of
files in an IM.

Endurance Zone
on Yahoo! Groups
Groups about
better endurance.
. __,_._,___ 

_________________________________________________________________
Download the latest version of Windows Live Messenger NOW!
http://get.live.com/en-ie/messenger/overview
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://assamnet.org/pipermail/assam_assamnet.org/attachments/20070903/6a45d4de/attachment.html 